| Platinum | East Side Mario's St. John's NF |
| Gold | St. John's Fish Exchange Kitchen & Wet Bar |
| Silver | The Merchant Tavern |
| Bronze | Evoo in the Courtyard |
| Top Pick | Bellissimo Bistro & Espresso Bar |
| Top Pick | No. 4 Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Oliver's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Little Sparo |
| Top Pick | The Salt House |
