| Platinum | Old Dublin Bakery |
| Gold | Sugar Mama's Bakery |
| Silver | Newfoundland Donut Co |
| Bronze | Cam's Confections |
| Top Pick | CakeyHand |
| Top Pick | Colemans Market |
| Top Pick | Dough By's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Georgestown Bakery |
| Top Pick | Mo' Treats |
| Top Pick | Roses Treats |
| Top Pick | Volcano Bakery |