| Platinum | Arbour Restaurant & Lounge |
| Gold | Piatto Pizzeria + Enoteca |
| Silver | Big Cheese Pizza Restaurant |
| Bronze | Acropolis Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ava's Convenience, Takeout & Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Black Cat Pizza |
| Top Pick | Donati's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Dough By's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Greco Pizza |
| Top Pick | Kilbride Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old Town Pizza |
| Top Pick | Topsail Road Pizzeria & Lounge |
| Top Pick | Venice Pizzeria |