| Platinum | CARSTAR St. John's |
| Gold | Healey's Auto Body Shop |
| Silver | Bodyworks St John's 2012 |
| Silver | King's Bridge Service Station |
| Bronze | Collision Clinic |
| Top Pick | A+ Plus Auto Center |
| Top Pick | Airport Autotech |
| Top Pick | Barton's Automotive Inc. |
| Top Pick | Capital Collision |
| Top Pick | Foxtrap Automotive |