| Platinum | Keith's Diner |
| Gold | The Jigger - Bay Bulls |
| Silver | Keith's Food Truck |
| Bronze | The Captain's Table |
| Top Pick | Chafe's Landing Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Landings Seafood House |
| Top Pick | St. John's Fish Exchange Kitchen & Wet Bar |
| Top Pick | Taylor's Fish, Fruit & Vegetable Market |
| Top Pick | The Duke Of Duckworth |
| Top Pick | The Post Taphouse |