| Platinum | Little Free Libraries |
| Gold | Elaine's Books |
| Silver | The Neverending Story Bookstore |
| Bronze | Downtown Comics |
| Top Pick | Adeys Attic Games and Collectibles |
| Top Pick | Heroes & Hobbies |
| Top Pick | SPCA Thrift Store East |
| Top Pick | SPCA Thrift Store West |
| Top Pick | Timemasters |